Another One (of the Absurdities) Bites The Dust

It's tragically stupid

This article appeared on the “Anti-Catholic Atheist”, aka “The Independent”. It deals with the widely publicised decision of the Archbishop of Melbourne to ban pop songs from…. Catholic funerals. I repeat the key words again: pop songs, Catholic funerals.

I must admit that I was blissfully unaware of the following facts:

1) That there are people who really have the effrontery to play pop songs at a funeral.
2) That it is even necessary that an Archbishop puts an end to all this.

I obviously knew that there were people who consider a funeral a “celebration” of the life of the deceased, in an obvious protestantisation of Catholicism that ignores Purgatory and tries to remove Hell. But I thought it was meant purely symbolically, as the attitude with which the relatives of the deceased approach the Funeral Mass.
What I didn’t know is that such “celebrations” would include football club songs and the like. Football songs? In Church? At a funeral?

Apparently, it got really extreme in Australia as the most popular songs played at funerals were, according to Australian funeral directors: “Queen’s “Another One Bites the Dust”, AC/DC’s “Highway to Hell”, the Monty Python ditty “Always Look on the Bright Side of Life”, and “Ding Dong the Witch is Dead”, from The Wizard of Oz.” I hope that such songs were never allowed at least in Catholic funerals, but I am afraid to ask……

More amusing is the attitude of the local “Independent” Atheist In Charge, Mssss. Kathy Marks, who had to explain to his readers what sacredness is and failed miserably.

Mssss. Marks does reports the Archbishop’s statement, so that his readers have at least a hint of what it is about, but the good woman insists on finding a trendy Catholic priest and letting him tell how oh bad and oh insensitive this decision is.
Our trendy chap of choice, called Father Maguire and he thinks that the decision is

“a bit insensitive to local sensibilities, and a reversal of grassroots Catholic rituals”

I’d like to know what a “grassroot” Catholic ritual is. Perhaps someone can help. I thought rituals had to be reverent, and that was that. The idea of the “sensitivities” is also funny, as if the Church should let the faithful decide how to do a funeral. Fr Maguire even hints at disobedience, saying that

“he would have to struggle to balance the needs of mourners against the law laid down by the church”.

“Balance”? He has to obey, hasn’t he?

Not satisfied, our chap (obviously on a highway to Hell of his own) tells us that:

“Around 10 per cent of Catholics will feel more comfortable with these sanitised rituals, but the other 90 per cent want these rituals to reflect their lives.”

It is bad enough that an obviously secular journalist can think that it be “insensitive” not to allow people to sing pop songs in a church at a funeral, as you never know what these journos have smoked in their youth; but that a Catholic Priest would make an ass of himself to such an extent is truly a sign of the times.

Still, always look on the bright side of life: the action of the Archbishop shows that these monstrosities are slowly dying. The sooner, the better.


Posted on September 13, 2010, in Catholicism and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 6 Comments.

  1. The sad thing is most Protestant churches would show far more reverance than this. I can’t stand desacralized music. My local parish employs a guitarist! I almost wish I was deaf.

    Mundabor, the Independent is horribly anti-Catholic but re anti-Catholic bias in the media I think you might be interested in this.

    (Brendan O’Neill is a Marxist atheist)

  2. Kudos to the Archbishop.

    FAO Fr Maguire:

    The priest as “community organiser” is way past its ‘sell by’ date.

  3. Yes, that’s it. Brendan is an excellent columnist. He’s actually a Marxist atheist.

%d bloggers like this: