“Conciliar Fathers”: A Lesson From Luther.

Heretic Nun-screwer. Thought that Communion had to be kneeling and on the tongue. What does this tell us about the "Conciliar Fathers"?

You may think that the title of this blog post is a joke, but it isn’t.

Taking Lessons from Luther is exactly what our heroes, the “Conciliar Fathers”, should have done once come back to their diocese after V II. Luther would have told them that communion must be:

1. kneeling, and
2. on the tongue

That much is what the great Athanasius Schneider has implied in an interview given to Radio Maria Suedtirol (= Alto Adige), in German, and reported by kreuz.net.

In the words of the Bishop:

„Die Lutheraner haben bis vor kurzem und bis heute noch in den skandinavischen Ländern die kniende Mundkommunion bewahrt.“

The Lutherans have preserved until a short time ago, and to this day in the Scandinavian countries, communion kneeling and on the tongue”.

According to him, the idea of communion in the hand in the way practiced today – the article goes in detail about the way communion was practised in the first centuries, and makes clear that the former, infinitely more reverent practice had been completely and, crucially, un-controversially abandoned by the V century – comes from the Calvinists.  And even in this case not from the original ones, but from Dutch Calvinists of the XVII century.

This means that even people who did not believe in the Real Presence managed to deal with the host in a more respectful way than the “Conciliar fathers” did once returned to their dioceses.

Go figure.

I do not know whether, when talking about the “Spirit of V II”, mockery or anger is more fitting; but I feel irresistibly attracted toward the second.


Posted on August 21, 2011, in Catholicism, Good Shepherds and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Comments Off on “Conciliar Fathers”: A Lesson From Luther..

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: