Reblog of the day

Mundabor's Blog

Reading around about the SSPX-Vatican talks, I can’t avoid making a couple of small considerations as follows:

1) It would seem there are some people who think if the SSPX does not agree with the Vatican, they will be declared schismatics.

This reasoning – very similar to those of the cave-in Catholics, though in this case some might be in good faith – is in my eyes fundamentally flawed. Being schismatic or orthodox is not something depending from the humour of the Pope of the day, much less – if we have a modicum of esteem for the current Pope – a matter object of emotional handling: if you do not agree with me now, I’ll declare you schismatic. Thank God, even the post-Vatican II Church is much better than this.

The Vatican cannot and will not declare the SSPX schismatic, because the Church cannot declare Herself schismatic

View original post 919 more words

Posted on April 30, 2012, in Catholicism. Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. Bishop Williamson should be set to one side in this discussion. I don’t think he will come over if there is a rapprochement.

    My view is that there IS a danger of a formal schism setting in – or being declared by the Holy See – if the current situation does not result in an agreement. We don’t know; I understand that, but in such a circumstance it would be difficult to remain with them.

    However, I do expect an agreement. In fact, I am highly optimistic. The Pope knows he doesn’t have much time left and he needs the SSPX on-board.

    • I still can’t imagine the alternative “either you are all fine, or you are schismatics”. Seriously, not even a child behaves this way. Well a child perhaps, but he must be very small.


  2. We’ll see soon enough. Please God no-one exercises any knee-jerk reactions. I’m sure the Holy Father will be under great pressure from the wolves to do just that.

    • Ah, but the Pope is of age now, is he not?

      He will sure be able to make his choice and bear the responsibility for it.

      I’ve written a post of it not many days ago.


  3. He has shown a determination, yes.

%d bloggers like this: