Synod: Instructions For Very Bad Popes

"Pastoral" device armed...

“Pastoral” device armed…


And so you are now, dear reader, a Pope. A Very Bad One. I mean, one of those Gandhi-cum-Dalai Lama people unable to go beyond the most banal platitudes, but so much in love with themselves they will do everything to please the world that lavishes praises on them.

One of the problems you have, my dear reader turned bad Pope, is the army of divorced Catholics who live with their lovers. This bothers you. Not, mind, because they live with their lovers; rather, because they lament your Church’s (and, by extension, yours) lack of approval for their behaviour. You like approval. These people are very loud. They think like the world, and the world likes them, and you want to be liked by the world. Ergo, you must do something for them.

Now: being a bad Pope, you also think that all these old notions of “judging others” should be discarded. If people are in good faith and follow their conscience, who are you to judge? A scribe? A hypocrite? A Holy Card face?

No, you have to do something there. Still, you realise that fundamental changes in the way the Church operates would cause a huge stir, and real doctrinal changes are not allowed to you anyway. After talking to your advisors – the homosexual friend of yours is a smart chap; yes, you know, but who are you to judge? – they suggest that you do the following:

1. Announce an extraordinary synod, taking your time: 13 or 14 months, say. This needs to be prepared carefully, you know.

2. Allow those most interested in material changes to make a lot of noise, demand shockingly sweeping reforms, and even create the expectation that they are now unavoidable. You will support them not openly, but clearly enough. You will talk generally of the necessity of “not judging”, and they will fill your slogan with the desired content. You will praise the one or other Cardinal on their side. But not too much. You are on the sidelines.

3. Wait for the unavoidable reaction and huge resistance, which you know will come. Allow the opposing camps to fight it to the knife; all the while inviting the contending parties to “tolerance”, “dialogue” and, of course, “charity”. At this point, the two sides have equal dignity. It’s not about right and wrong, you will let it transpire; rather, it is about how mercy must be lived in these oh so new times of ours, in which new phenomena, unknown to humanity before, have appeared: like sluttish wives and horny husbands, broken marriages and public concubines. If the Cardinals are against you, you will use the bishops – far more numerous, younger, and hungrier – to let things go your way. It’s not you, you see. It must be the “Spirit”. You will talk about the “Spirit” a lot; because like parsley, the “Spirit” can be used everywhere.

4. At the very end, intervene with a solution that whilst negating to the reformers the absurdly unrealistic changes they have pretended to demand, concedes to them vastly more than what would have been feasible if the unrealistic and absurd demands had not been made in the first place. You have listened to everyone. You have noticed the cry for help, the need for reform. You can feel the “Spirit” work. The reforms of VII must be continued. We live in the time of mercy now.

At this point, you have delivered for your friends more than they could ever dream of, whilst being presented by your useful idiots – a Pope has never any scarcity of those – as a merciful, conservative Pope wisely steering the Church through difficult times. Countless bloggers will praise your delicate and pastoral hand, and the Catholic Press will start to prepare the faithful for your now allegedly unavoidable canonisation.

5. This is the consolidation phase, the maintenance programme, but also the harvest time. The world will rejoice. You have delivered again. The secular press will point out to how much you are demolishing, er, modernising, the way the Church understands Herself. They will send to their readers the clear message that the Church was always wrong anyway, and you get it; that you are now destroying all that can reasonably be destroyed considering the constraints of your position; that whilst still the Pope, you are on their side. They will still feebly criticise you at times – for example, for not openly celebrating sodomy – but this will work for you just fine, as the Pollyannas’ Army will immediately pick up every criticism to shout to the world how orthodox you are. “Is the Pope Catholic?”, they will ask, smiling. Business as usual, folks. Nothing to look at; or, as the Italian guard would say: circolare, circolare!

At this point, your victory will be almost total. Yes, a minority of party-poopers will insist in criticising you. They will do so vocally, insistently, for as long as you live. They will use harsh words. But you are prepared. You will launch the Pollyannas’ Army against them; you will talk all the time about the “judgmental” people, the “hypocrites”, the “Neo-Pelagians”. You will call them all sorts of names and insult them in all possible ways, whilst repeating without pause that we must not be judgmental. They will never be destroyed, but they won’t be much in your way, either, at least if things go according to plan. You will, in fact, try to use them to present yourself as the innocent victim of “judgmentalism”, the man of mercy criticised by two-dimensional, holy-card-like “people of the law”.

Dear reader and bad Pope, as a I write this you are at point 2, and everything is going according to plan. Point 3 will be a huge shock for Catholics, but it will work well for you. Point 4 will be the most difficult for you personally. Point 5 might be challenging but, given time, perfectly doable.

At every moment, you will be free to backpedal if you see the game is getting too dangerous. You will be, at all times, the one who calls the shots, the one who brakes publicly and sends covert messages it is time to put the foot on the gas again. Nothing will be directly attributed to you until the very end; and when the end game comes you will be seen to merely react, wisely and pastorally, to external circumstances, whilst listening to the Spirit.

So do not worry. Allow other people to fight your fight. But you, you just stay calm: kiss children, embrace wheelchairs, stay near to the cameras, and prepare the ground.

There’s no downside for you. You will get out of this as the winner anyway.

The world is such a fool.




Posted on April 2, 2014, in Catholicism, Conservative Catholicism, Traditional Catholicism and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 14 Comments.

  1. You hit the nail on the head, Mundabor. It would be funny if it were not so depressing.

    Twenty years ago a famous leftist German psychoanalyst published a novel with the title „Die hohe Kunst der Korruption –Erkenntnisse eines Politikberaters“. (The fine art of corruption – Insights of a political advisor). It was a shocking book because reading it one knew immediately that the story was no fiction.
    You could have contributed a second volume: “Insights of an ecclesiastical advisor”!

    BTW, is it just by chance that your small manual for Church reform reads like an Alinskyan “call to action” or “community organizing”?

  2. It may be necessary to de-canonize saints like Thomas More who died rather than approve a certain somewhat notorious divorce and remarriage but I’m sure that can be arranged.

  3. Your best post on the up coming synod. I pray that what you say does not come to pass but I fear that you have laid out the BOR’s strategy perfectly.

  4. Great overview of what we Holy Card Face Wannabes should expect. Your ability to describe, distill and instruct is remarkable.

  5. Just an FYI~I had to reconfigure my WordPress account with a recent move and getting access to Louie V’s comment box. I like my new name better! Miss my old Gravatar, but new BVM not bad, eh?

  6. Let’s hope the Bishop of Rome and the troops of Kasperini won’t use your article as a ‘battleground handbook’ in view of the Synod….Jokes apart , if the most conservative and traditionalist Cardinals too read this analysis of the Church Demolishers’ mentality ,as it will most probably operate before , during and especially after the October Synod , they shall not be ‘ caught off guard ‘ like it has often happened during the last decades . Enough with the ‘If only I had known ‘ , ‘ I couldn’t ever have imagined ‘ . Someone must prepare ,begin and organize for the future the counterattack , the active resistance inside the Vatican . The cost will be high ,probably a schism of the German-speaking countries . If they are still in love with ‘their’ Luther, let it be .Let’s not repeat farces like the ‘dialogue’ with Dutch dissenters and the LCWR -likes. Almost fifty years of bufooneries , of false unity. Didn’t Christ say to Judas ‘ what you have to do ,do it soon ‘?
    Mundabor , haven’t you forgot to add something to the first three lines ? Sort of Gandhi-cum Dalai Lama et Mandela ? Where has Mandela gone ?

  7. greatpretender51

    On your Point 4: I’d bet the solution will be, as it has been so frequently during the Conciliar era, to allow the national Bishops’ Conferences to make certain “pastoral” decisions on these cases. At that point, of course, some Freemason/heretic/modernist/progressive/useful idiot point man in one or more Conference will jump in and set the precedent, and there you go down the slippery slope…this scenario has been used time and time again.

  8. I think it’s been pretty plain to see that he is getting bishops and cardinals to do his dirty work for him. He’ll just give all the power over to them, in the end.He’ll probably even graciously step aside- for the anti-Christ. Biblical false prophet.

%d bloggers like this: